How Do You Sell a $750K+ Resale Home When New Construction Is Competing Nearby?

Seller Tips · Market Update · Southwest Wake County

How Do You Sell a $750K+ Resale Home When New Construction Is Competing Nearby?

Compete on what a builder can't copy, and price against the builder's finished price, not its base price. In Apex, Cary, Holly Springs and Fuquay-Varina, $750K+ resales and homes built in 2025–26 sold at the same $925,000 median and about the same size. The difference was land: resales sat on a median 0.30 acre, new homes on 0.19.

If you own a $750,000-plus home in Southwest Wake, there's a good chance a builder is selling brand-new homes a few miles away, sometimes in the next phase of your own community. That competition is real. But Wake County's sales records show it isn't one-sided. Here's what the numbers say about new versus resale at the upper end of the market, and how I'd prepare and price a resale to stand out.

How much of the $750K+ market is new construction?

From November 2025 through September 2026, Wake County recorded 1,273 qualified single-family sales at $750,000 or more inside the town limits of Apex, Cary, Holly Springs and Fuquay-Varina. Of those, 355 (28%) were homes built in 2025 or 2026, which I use here as a stand-in for new construction. The share varies a lot by town:

Town$750K+ salesBuilt 2025–26Resale medianNew medianResale median lotNew median lot
Apex30841%$940,000$851,0000.26 acre0.17 acre
Holly Springs21635%$895,000$860,0000.30 acre0.22 acre
Cary65416%$945,000$1,004,0000.31 acre0.18 acre
Fuquay-Varina9549%$811,250$929,5000.35 acre0.36 acre
All four towns1,27328%$925,000$925,0000.30 acre0.19 acre

Source: Wake County Tax Administration, Qualified Sales, Past 24 Months (downloaded Nov 11, 2026). In-town sales coded single-family, sale type "Package," $750,000 and up, Nov 1, 2025–Sep 30, 2026. "New" means year built 2025 or 2026. Lot size is deeded acreage from county records. Medians are rounded.

In Apex and Holly Springs, the typical $750K+ resale sold for more than the typical new home. In Cary and Fuquay-Varina, new homes carried the higher median. Either way, buyers in this price range are regularly choosing between the two.

Where does a resale have the edge?

  • Land. Across the four towns, the median $750K+ resale sat on 0.30 acre, against 0.19 acre for new homes. In Apex and Cary, resale lots were roughly half again as large or more.
  • Size for the money in some towns. In Holly Springs, new $750K+ homes sold at a median of about $288 per heated square foot, versus about $253 for resales. In Apex, resales were also larger: a median of 3,673 square feet against 3,431.
  • A finished setting. Established streets, mature trees and completed landscaping are things a buyer can see on day one. A new phase may still be under construction around them.
  • Move-in timing. A resale can close on a set date. New-construction buyers depend on the builder's schedule unless the home is already finished.

A builder sells a floor plan. You're selling a finished home on a lot nobody can build anymore. Price and present it that way.

Where does new construction have the edge?

Being honest about this is how you price well. New homes offer builder warranties, current floor plans, new systems and finishes the buyer picks. Builders also sometimes advertise incentives, like help with closing costs or a lower interest rate, that a buyer weighs against your price. Ask your listing agent to tour the competing communities and collect each builder's current incentives in writing. Then you're comparing against real numbers, not brochures.

How should you price a resale against a builder?

Start with the builder's finished price, not the advertised "from" price. A model's base price often leaves out lot premiums, structural options and design-center selections. Compare like with like: square footage, bedrooms and baths, garage, lot size and level of finish. Then add or subtract for what's different.

Age matters inside the resale market too. Among the 918 resale sales at $750K+ across the four towns, homes built in the 2010s had the highest median price, $980,000. Homes built before 2000 sold at a median of $900,000, with the highest price per square foot (about $294), largely because they were smaller. My guide to how to price your home walks through building that comparison, and my pricing strategy page explains why the first two weeks on the market matter so much.

What should you fix or prepare before listing?

When the competition is brand new, buyers notice wear more. Focus on the items a new-construction buyer would never have to think about:

  • Systems and roof. Have the age and service history of the HVAC, water heater and roof ready. A pre-listing inspection can surface issues before a buyer's inspector does.
  • Paint, lighting and flooring. These are the most visible differences between your home and a model home.
  • The lot. Clean beds, trimmed trees and a usable backyard sell the one thing you have that builders often don't: space.
  • Disclosure. Complete the North Carolina Residential Property and Owners' Association Disclosure Statement carefully, and gather receipts for improvements.

My guide to preparing your home for market has a fuller checklist.

How should you market a resale against new homes?

Lead with what the data says sets resales apart. Put the lot size, the yard and the setting up front in the photos and the description, not buried after the kitchen. Show the backyard in daylight and from the back of the lot looking at the house, so buyers can see the space. If your neighborhood has amenities that are already finished and in use, say so plainly. Keep a simple one-page list of updates with dates, so buyers can compare your systems and finishes with a builder's spec sheet on equal terms. And be ready with a realistic closing date, since a buyer waiting on a home that's still being built can't always count on one.

Figures are closed, qualified sales from Wake County public records. They don't include listing data like days on market, list price or builder incentives. They describe homes and prices only and aren't a guarantee of what any home will sell for.

Sources:

  • Wake County Tax Administration. "Qualified Sales, Past 24 Months" (downloaded Nov 11, 2026). www.wake.gov

Selling near new construction?

I can help you price your home against what builders are really getting, and prepare it so buyers see what a new home can't offer.

See what your home could sell for

Frequently Asked Questions

Do resale homes sell for less than new construction in Southwest Wake?

Not overall. From November 2025 through September 2026, $750K+ resales and homes built in 2025 or 2026 in Apex, Cary, Holly Springs and Fuquay-Varina both sold at a median of $925,000, according to Wake County qualified sales.

How much of the $750K+ market in Apex and Holly Springs is new construction?

About 41% of qualified $750K+ single-family sales in Apex and 35% in Holly Springs from November 2025 through September 2026 were homes built in 2025 or 2026. In Cary, the share was about 16%.

What advantage does a resale home have over new construction?

Usually land and setting. The median $750K+ resale in the four towns sat on 0.30 acre, compared with 0.19 acre for new homes, and resales come with established landscaping and a set closing date.

Should I price my home against a builder's base price?

No. Compare against the builder's finished price, including lot premiums, options and upgrades, and against current builder incentives. Base prices often leave those out.

LW

Leonna Weiss

Weiss Choice Realty · KW Legacy

Leonna Weiss is a top-producing real estate agent and the lead of Weiss Choice Realty with Keller Williams Legacy, bringing over 12 years of experience to the Raleigh metro area in North Carolina. Backed by 170+ five-star reviews, her team specializes in helping buyers and sellers navigate residential real estate transactions across Raleigh, Cary, Apex, Holly Springs, Fuquay-Varina and surrounding communities.

Next
Next

How Do Greenways Compare in Cary, Apex, Holly Springs and Fuquay-Varina?